Users wrote

Undertale is widely praised for its story, music, and characters. Reviewers say the choices you make matter and lead to different endings. The humor and meta writing are frequently highlighted as a big strength. Some reviews note pacing issues or the difficulty of certain routes, but the overall consensus is that it's a landmark indie game with emotional impact.

Last updated: 2026-03-01

Most Mentioned Advantages

• Compelling story and memorable characters (70 mentions) - Undertale's writing and characters are repeatedly praised. Reviewers mention a memorable story that blends humor, warmth, and moments of sadness. The world and cast feel alive and unique, with characters like Toriel, Sans, and Papyrus becoming iconic. The story's emotional beats and clever dialogue leave a lasting impression and encourage replays to see different outcomes.
• Iconic music and sound design (60 mentions) - Many reviews highlight the soundtrack as a standout element. Reviewers say the music fits each scene perfectly and enhances the mood of every area and boss fight. The sound design contributes to the emotional impact and helps make the game memorable. The music is described as iconic and frequently cited across plays.
• Humor and charm (55 mentions) - Reviewers frequently praise Undertale's humor and witty dialogue. The writing is described as charming and meta, balancing heavier moments. The humor helps players connect with the characters and remember the game long after finishing.
• Multiple endings and meaningful choices (50 mentions) - Players can pursue pacifist, genocide, or neutral routes, and the game rewards choices with different endings. Reviewers note that conversations and battles influence the outcome, adding replayability. The system makes actions feel meaningful and not merely cosmetic. Many say this is a major strength that adds value beyond a single playthrough.
• Emotional impact and tears (45 mentions) - Several reviews report crying or strong emotional responses during endings or pivotal scenes. The combination of story, music, and character arcs creates lasting emotional resonance. Many say the emotional weight is a key reason for Undertale's enduring popularity.

Most Mentioned Disadvantages

• Genocide path is very difficult (30 mentions) - Some players find the genocide route extremely challenging and punishing. The combat can be tough and requires practice. This difficulty can be off-putting for players who want a lighter pace.
• Dialogue heavy and pacing slow (20 mentions) - Many reviews mention lengthy dialogue and chat-heavy sections. This can slow down pacing between battles and exploration. The game would benefit from skip-chat options or faster progress for some players.
• Limited save slots (12 mentions) - Several reviewers note issues with saving, mentioning few or limited save slots. This can hinder experimentation across routes. It may require careful planning to avoid losing progress.
• Graphics are simple / retro (10 mentions) - Some reviewers comment that the visuals are simple and retro. While many enjoy the pixel art style, others see it as a downside compared to modern visuals. This is not a major issue for many, but it is noted as a potential drawback.
• Some sections feel repetitive or slow between fights (7 mentions) - Certain parts of the game feel repetitive or slow for some players. This can reduce engagement during non-combat segments. The pacing of some sections may not suit every player.

Compared Games

• Earthbound (8 mentions) - Several reviewers compare Undertale to Earthbound for its quirky tone and subversive storytelling. The games share a similar vibe and influence on indie RPGs.
• Deltarune (5 mentions) - Some reviewers reference Deltarune as Toby Fox's next project and mention Undertale as the original inspiration. They note fan interest in future chapters.
• Hollow Knight (3 mentions) - A few reviewers place Undertale in high regard alongside other acclaimed indies like Hollow Knight, showing its standing among favorites.
• Batman: Arkham City (2 mentions) - One reviewer compares Undertale's narrative weight to Batman: Arkham City, noting strong storytelling.